BIROn - Birkbeck Institutional Research Online

    The space between second-personal respect and rational care in theory and mental health law

    Kong, Camillia (2015) The space between second-personal respect and rational care in theory and mental health law. Law and Philosophy , ISSN 0167-5249.

    [img] Text
    Law and Philosophy.pdf - Published Version of Record
    Restricted to Repository staff only

    Download (862kB)
    25451.pdf - Author's Accepted Manuscript

    Download (341kB) | Preview


    In recent human rights and legal instruments, individuals with impairments are increasingly recognised as agents who are worthy of respect for their inherent dignity and capacity to make autonomous decisions regarding treatment and care provisions. These legal developments could be understood using Stephen Darwall’s normative framework of the second person standpoint. However, this paper draws upon phenomena – both in legal developments and recent court cases – to illustrate theoretical difficulties with the contractualist underpinnings of Darwall’s account if applied to questions of what is owed to individuals with disabilities. I argue that, under Darwall’s framework, whether the threshold for second-personal competence has been met will determine whether respect or rational care is owed to them. This fact distorts our understanding of what we owe to persons with mental impairments—in part because it limits respect to relations that are symmetrical and reciprocal. In light of these challenges the paper offers an account of hermeneutic competency, which can be applied to non-reciprocal and asymmetrical relationships. This alternative account will be of practical import to judicial determinations of best interests under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 in England and Wales. It will also be of broader theoretical interest to any legal system that deals with people with mental disabilities.


    Item Type: Article
    Keyword(s) / Subject(s): Second-person standpoint, Respect, Care, Darwall Contractualism, Dignity, Mental health law, Best interests, Hermeneutics, Anorexia nervosa
    School: Birkbeck Faculties and Schools > Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences > School of Social Sciences
    Research Centres and Institutes: Crime & Justice Policy Research, Institute for
    Depositing User: Camillia Kong
    Date Deposited: 12 Dec 2018 16:17
    Last Modified: 02 Aug 2023 17:47


    Activity Overview
    6 month trend
    6 month trend

    Additional statistics are available via IRStats2.

    Archive Staff Only (login required)

    Edit/View Item Edit/View Item