GMO authorisations and The Aarhus Regulation: paving the way for precautionary GMO governance?

Leonelli, Giulia Claudia (2019) GMO authorisations and The Aarhus Regulation: paving the way for precautionary GMO governance? Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 26 (4), pp. 505-523. ISSN 1023-263X.

Abstract

This article endeavours to assess whether existing case law under the Aarhus Regulation has opened up any opportunities for civil society to challenge the decision that, in the face of scientific uncertainty, GMO risks meet the intended EU level of health and environmental protection. Against this backdrop, it seeks to establish whether the actions of NGOs under the Aarhus Regulation have resulted in any meaningful review of the Commission’s exercise of its discretion, in accordance with the overarching tenets of the precautionary principle and the aim of a high level of health and environmental protection. Upon an in depth analysis of the recent TestBioTech cases the article puts forward an argument for different evidentiary rules and a different standard of review in Aarhus Regulation case law, advocating a clearer distinction between ‘standard’ action for annulment and annulment of a decision to reject a request for internal review. This is argued to be the only way forward to breathe some life into the Aarhus Regulation’s provisions, ensuring some scrutiny of the level of protection achieved and nudging the Commission to take the precautionary principle seriously in the GMO field.

Metadata

Statistics

DownloadsShow export options

Export as XMLJSONCSV

Activity Overview

6 month trend

354Downloads

6 month trend

172Hits

Additional statistics are available via IRStats2.

Archive Staff Only (login required)

Edit/View Item