'Shoot the messenger': dynamics of positioning and denial in response to human rights appeals

Seu, Irene Bruna (2011) 'Shoot the messenger': dynamics of positioning and denial in response to human rights appeals. Journal of Human Rights Practice 3 (2), pp. 131-169. ISSN 1757-9619.

Abstract

This article offers a psychosocial discursive analysis of audiences’ responses to information about human rights abuses. The analysis of focus group members’ justifications for their inaction is informed by a view of language as social action and Cohen’s concept of denial, with its focus on the culturally available accounts of justifications and excuses that form the vocabulary of moral passivity within our society. Positioning theory is applied to study participants’ moral positioning and the storylines used to account for their passivity, with a specific focus on the use of negative positioning of Amnesty International and charities in general. Four storylines – ‘trust and truthfulness’, ‘misuse of resources’, ‘effectiveness of proposed action’, and ‘money and manipulation’ – are discussed in terms of how participants use them to weaken the standing of the appeal makers and to ascribe a moral position to themselves, whilst remaining passive to the appeal. The article discusses the implications of such positioning for the local moral order, its wider cultural significance, and its implications for campaigning. It claims that the relationship between appeal makers and potential moral actors is an important factor in fostering or hindering social responsibility and collective action. As such, it argues for increased attention to be paid to it by researchers.

Metadata

Statistics

DownloadsShow export options

Export as XMLJSONCSV

Activity Overview

6 month trend

3Downloads

6 month trend

391Hits

Additional statistics are available via IRStats2.

Archive Staff Only (login required)

Edit/View Item